Common questions I get asked in practice about employee’s criminal convictions are:
Essentially, the answers to these questions to depend to some extent on the area of work where that individual is engaged to work in. For example, it is important that people with certain convictions do not undertake certain types of work (for example, ensuring that those convicted of child sex offences do not have access to children).
The law in this area tries to maintain a balance between an individual’s right to privacy and an employer’s right to protect vulnerable groups of individuals.
There is no overriding obligation on an individual to voluntarily disclose their whole criminal record to a current or prospective employer.
So, how can an employer find out about an individual’s full criminal record? The most obvious way for an employer to find out if a person has a criminal record is to ask them voluntarily. The drawback here is that there is no obligation on a job applicant, employee, worker, or volunteer to voluntarily disclose their criminal record to a current or prospective employer. Therefore, employers have to rely on the honesty of the individual.
However, where a job or vacancy is covered by an ‘exception’, an employer may be able to access official records of an individual’s criminal record, in order to get full and accurate details of that individual’s criminal record. This is done through the Disclosure and Barring Service (DBS).
But, what must and must not be disclosed? What can and can’t be considered by the employer?
There is a difference in the types of criminal convictions that employers may have access to. These are known as ‘spent’ and ‘unspent’ convictions:
Most ‘spent’ convictions do not need to be disclosed to a future or current employer, even where the employer makes a direct request for that information or that there is a contractual requirement for the individual to disclose their convictions. However, there may be issues relating to the implied term of mutual trust and confidence triggered here if the individual is not truthful (see below).
There are however exceptions to this rule, as there are certain professional bodies and employers (such as solicitors, and those that work with children and vulnerable adults) that are permitted to request an individual’s full criminal record revealing all spent convictions; no matter how historic or minor the offence.
Generally, unspent criminal convictions should be disclosed by an individual voluntarily and would show up on a DBS check.
Once an employer finds out about a criminal conviction they may wish to dismiss a current employee or refuse to offer employment to that particular applicant. Is this lawful?
The answer will depend on the particular circumstances, for example:
The best practice for employers, in circumstances where they are making their own judgement on the weight of an individual’s criminal record (i.e. they are not bound by sector-specific protocols or regulations), is that they should take into account the following:
Employers should not have a blanket ban employing ex-offenders. Employers with good recruitment policies are likely to have other means by which they can assess an applicant’s suitability, such as checking qualifications and taking up references.
Remember, employers can always make good use of probationary periods, and providing a clear job description will allow an employer to assess the suitability of an individual’s performance of the job in question.
If you would like any further advice on employee’s criminal convictions or any other aspect of employment law, please contact a member of our Employment & HR team.
Derby Head Office:
St. Michael’s Court
St. Michael’s Lane
Derby
DE1 3HQ
Tel: 01332 340 211
Fax: 01332 207 601
DX: 729320 Derby 24
Ashbourne:
54, St. John Street
Ashbourne
Derbyshire
DE6 1GH
Tel: 01335 342 208
Fax: 01335 342 010
DX: 26834 Ashbourne
Opening Times:
Our offices are open Monday to
Friday between 8:00am & 6:00pm