01332 340 211

Changes to grievances and the disciplinary process

A recent case has decided that employers do not always need to complete a grievance procedure before they dismiss an employee.

There is often confusion between employers and employees as to the correct procedure to follow where the employer initiates a disciplinary process and the employee subsequently raises a grievance relating to the same issues. Employees tend to want to have their grievances dealt with in full before the disciplinary process starts and request that the disciplinary process stays whilst their grievance is heard.

This can lead to increased costs for employers who feel obliged to keep employers on the payroll whilst their grievances are dealt with even where the employee has committed an act of gross misconduct which would justify summary dismissal. It may also result in duplication if the issues are first to be considered for the purposes of the grievance and then again as part of the disciplinary procedure.

The Employment Appeal Tribunal gave updated guidance on grievances and the disciplinary process

The Employment Appeal Tribunal (EAT) has now given some much-needed guidance in this area. In the case of Samuel Smith Old Brewery (Tadcaster) v Marshall and another UKEAT/0488/09 it was decided that the employer, who had dismissed an employee before the grievance appeal had been completed, had not dismissed unfairly.

The EAT commented that it will only be in very rare cases that an employer’s decision not to complete the grievance procedure before dismissing an employee will, in itself, amount to unfair dismissal. They observed that there is nothing in the ACAS code which obliges employers to conclude the grievance process prior to dismissal.

The EAT took the view, in this case, that where the employee attended a disciplinary hearing they would have had the opportunity raise and discuss grievances at that stage and so a separate grievance procedure would not be necessary.

For further information and support, please contact our Employment & HR team.

< Back
All News >


Contact us


If you have received a letter from our Debt Recovery team, please refer to the contact details provided in the letter to ensure your enquiry is dealt with promptly by the correct member of our team.

For all other enquiries, please complete the form below.

Derby Head Office:
St. Michael’s Court
St. Michael’s Lane
Tel: 01332 340 211
Fax: 01332 207 601
DX: 729320 Derby 24
SRA number: 509657

54, St. John Street
Tel: 01335 342 208
Fax: 01335 342 010
DX: 26834 Ashbourne
SRA number: 511804

Opening Times:
Our offices are open Monday to
Friday between 08:00 & 18:00

Contact us