Georgina Davis promoted to Partner
Congratulations to Georgina Davis who has been promoted to Partner within Finance Dispute Resolution.
Read More
Flint Bishop’s Commercial Litigation team has again made the national law reports, securing a win in the Court of Appeal following earlier High Court success.
4 October 2021
News
Solicitor Kelly Savage, along with counsel Daniel Goodkin of 4 Pump Court, successfully represented the Claimants in the second highest court in the English legal system.
After a full day of legal argument in the Court of Appeal in London, in a hearing live-streamed on the Court of Appeal video channel, three renowned appeal judges, Lord Justices Arnold, Popplewell and Coulson handed down their written judgments today. The appeal judges unanimously dismissed the Defendants’ appeal on all grounds, upholding the victory secured in the earlier High Court judgment.
There were two issues before the Court of Appeal. The first was that for many years, online property giants Rightmove and Zoopla have informed their members that online lettings agents cannot place adverts for properties to be let by other lettings agencies. This was important to the Claimants as they were alleged to be in breach of warranties following a corporate transaction comprising of the sale of an online property lettings company.
The High Court judge had decided that Rightmove’s and Zoopla’s terms did not have the contractual effect they have consistently put forward and did not prevent online lettings agents from placing adverts for other lettings agents. The Court of Appeal has now upheld this decision.
The second issue concerned the meaning of “non-disclosure” in the context of a warranty limitation of liability clause within the corporate transaction sale and purchase agreement. This was important to the Claimants in being able to rely on disclosures that were outside of the disclosure letter for the purposes of the Defendants’ attempts to overcome a contractual time limit for warranty claims.
The High Court judge had decided that the analysis of any “non-disclosure” was not limited to the disclosure letter. The Court of Appeal also upheld this decision.
Kelly Savage commented on the decision:
“Having identified two questions to tactically put before the Court for summary judgment, with a view to improving the Claimants’ position within the litigation and reducing costs in the long term, it is a great relief and source of pride that the High Court and the Court of Appeal agreed with our analysis on the interpretation of the key contractual provisions.
We also managed to secure full costs awards following both hearings, meaning that we have secured important judgments on two key principles within the claim without any net cost to the Claimants, which is even more satisfying.”
The High Court judgment can be read here: Butcher and another v Pike and others [2020] EWHC 3362 (QB)
The Court of Appeal judgment can be read here: Butcher and another v Pike and others [2021] EWCA civ 1407 (09 September 2021).
Contact Us
For more information about this case or any commercial litigation matter, please call 01332 226 104 or fill in the form below.
News
Congratulations to Georgina Davis who has been promoted to Partner within Finance Dispute Resolution.
Read MoreFlint Bishop appoints Deborah Niven as Partner & Head of IP, boosting northern commercial and innovation sector expertise.
Read MoreFive experienced conveyancers join Flint Bishop in Derby, strengthening local expertise and client service across the Midlands.
Read MoreKelly Savage and Catherine Marksman have been promoted to Partner, recognising their leadership, expertise, and contributions to the firm.
Read MoreFlint Bishop retains Investors in People Gold, highlighting commitment to staff development, culture, and continuous improvement.
Read MoreFlint Bishop appoints Nomaan Tahir as Head of Commercial Finance, strengthening FP&A capability and embedding strategic financial insight across the firm.
Read MoreFlint Bishop makes strategic appointment of former Walker Morris Managing Partner to lead its North Division
Read MoreFlint Bishop achieves national recognition in Chambers UK 2026 with record rankings and recognised lawyers.
Read MoreFlint Bishop achieves record results in The Legal 500 UK 2026 with 17 ranked practice areas and 44 recognised individuals.
Read MoreFlint Bishop acquires Lupton Fawcett, expanding northern UK presence and strengthening expertise across key sectors.
Read MoreFlint Bishop announces three newly qualified solicitors, strengthening its Insurance Litigation, Commercial Property, and Corporate & Finance teams.
Read MoreFlint Bishop welcomes Jay Hall as a Title Rectification Associate, enhancing expertise in title rectification and defective security.
Read MoreScroll to next section
Scroll back to the top
On Monday 29 September, Flint Bishop successfully completed the acquisition of the entire business of Lupton Fawcett LLP. You have been forwarded to the page most relevant to your visit.
Please feel free to explore our website and learn more about our legal services and professionals, including those who have recently joined us from Lupton Fawcett.